atomeyes wrote:a polite question: you married?
yup! but my wife is pretty spectacular.
atomeyes wrote:my wife was relatively supportive with me converting an unused basement closet into a beer cellar and was impressed with the shelves i've installed. but the brewing equipment and the beer have taken up a nice portion of our basement. i would need to install shelving units to take care of the mess i've created; instead, when we finally reno our basement in 2 years, i'll just tear down a corner of the basement and build a proper climate controlled wine/beer cellar. mmmm.....cellars...
i'm probably taking up half of my basement between fermenters, cellaring beer, barrel, kegs, kegerator, bulk grain, etc... but what else would i be doing with the space? as hobbies go, it could certainly be worse.
atomeyes wrote:but when i talked to her about making or buying a kegerator, she was a little concerned. bloody easy to go down to the basement and pour beer. think that's the part that scares her. the ease of access.
why is that scary? don't you have a stockpile of beer/wine/liquor that's equally as accessible now? what's the difference between walking down for a couple pints vs a couple bottles? especially if it's your homebrew... 5gal of beer is 5gal of beer, regardless of the container it's served from.
atomeyes wrote:also, one can argue that kegging takes as much work as bottling. cleaning kegs, sanitizing lines, etc etc.
i can only imagine someone who's never kegged saying that. there is no way the two are even comparable. filling a keg takes 15min and requires no intervention (ie: i can be working on other beer chores while it fills). cleaning and sanitizing takes 15min tops. then you're at 30min end to end to package 5gal. oh right! don't forget 5min to clean/sanitize your lines, so call it 35min.
if i'm bottling, first i need to prep my bottles. there's at least the one-time cost of label removal that's a minimum of an hour for a batch worth. already double the time for a keg, but you don't pay that every time. generally they always get a rinse and check for cleanliness if i'm reusing, so call that an easy 15-30min/batch... definitely longer than cleaning a keg.
assuming i've got clean bottles ready, they need to be sanitized. probably 15min to get them rinsed and on the tree. comparable to the combined clean+sanitize time for a keg.
before you can actually bottle, you gotta figure out your priming, boil up some sugar, cool (possibly), and add to your beer. 15min boil plus the bells and whistles, probably 30ish end to end.
now we're on to filling. first lose is that the bottle filling is totally interactive. solo bottling 5gal is going to take you an easy hour, slightly faster if you've got someone else to cap while you fill, but that filling is always going to be slower than filling a keg.
add that all up and i don't think you'll find a way to convince yourself that kegging is "just as much work" as bottling.
atomeyes wrote:in the end, ... i'm not in the mood to crush $$ into a kegerator. money is money. they aren't cheap, but bottle cleaning costs only man hours.
meh, fair enough. you can do it cheap, but as you say, money is money. time is money too though, and if i can fill 4 kegs in a couple hours (actually less since you can be doing things in parallel) and the same would take me all day to bottle, my time is worth the one-time cost to get kegs going. plus if you start small and build on it, you're just doing a little cash here and there (and bonus if you can get folks to contribute $$ for birthdays/holidays/etc).