Belgian wrote:I cannot fathom why if you have only 24 beer, you pay zero duty on those 24, but if you buy say 48 beer, you pay duty and tax on all 48 (ie. you don't get a break on the first 24.) I think they did this to me once with only 36.
Gotta scare the sheep so they don't stray too far.
Huh? When I've crossed the border on under two day trips (no exemption) then I've paid duty on the whole amount whether it was 24, 48 or much more, since none is exempt. But trips of over two days (having a 24 bottle exemption) I've even been able to choose which of the beers over 24 were exempt and which weren't...meaning I could exempt the more expensive ones and only pay for the cheaper ones. My last trip across the Manitoba border from Wisconsin was actually quite comical. I had an assortment of 355ml bottles, 330ml bottles, 500ml cans, 650ml bombers, 750ml bottles, litre bottles and a growler. I declared honestly, got waved in and took my receipts inside. The clerk was a young 20's girl who was frankly baffled by my haul. I suppose she usually sees only 24's of Bud which makes the math pretty easy. Since I had mixed sizes she told me the limit in metric (roughly 8.5L) and then let ME do the math and tell her how much over I was and the value of those bottles only. I circled the ones I decided to pay for on the receipt! That was how she calculated my duty and tax...which ended up being barely 10% of my total purchase price.
Frankly I often feel that the more of a pain in the ass the calculation is the more likely they are to let you off easy. There seems to be a lot of discretion as to how they calculate your payable and I have NEVER had anyone subsequently ask to see the beer itself, they just care about the receipts.
As an aside, avoid crossing with beer into B.C. The tax and duty work out to approximately 85% of the purchase price. For example, a six of Stone IPA I paid $10 U.S. for in Bellingham was $18.50 Canadian when all was said and done (granted, back when the exchange was at around 75 cents on the U.S. dollar). Considering the massive amount of reasonably priced quality U.S. micros available in B.C. it mostly isn't worth it.
I don't always piss in a bottle but when I do...I prefer to call it Dos Equis.